Paperchase recently found themselves where no brand wants to be – at the heart of a Twitterstorm. Social media users were quick to express their dismay when the company placed a promotion in the Daily Mail. Paperchase soon withdrew the promotion, apologising and announcing they wouldn’t do it again. But, as is often the way, this led to another camp accusing Paperchase of ‘giving in to the Twitter mob’.

Question: could a branded online community have helped?

A dedicated, distraction-free platform

Communities can definitely help in a crisis. First of all, on a dedicated platform, brands have members’ undivided attention.  On Facebook or Twitter there are friends, family and countless other brands vying for users’ attention. With a dedicated platform, an attentive public, and nothing else but your brand, in crisis situations you have the perfect place to discuss issues with your customers.

Paperchase certainly had people sharing their views. But the difficulty with public social media is that it’s hard to verify whether feedback comes from genuine brand-engaged customers, or simply from those who have weighed in with their opinion. With their own community, Paperchase could have tackled this problem head on, while proving beyond doubt (with statistics and data) that those expressing concern were representative of their brand.

A place to inform the disgruntled

Another benefit of a branded community is that it provides a place for people on public social media to access a brand. In this situation, Paperchase could have explained their intentions, decision-making process and what they intended to do about the problem with much greater ease than on character-limited Twitter.

Not only this, but your community also offers ongoing discussion, in real time.  When something goes wrong with a product or service, brands can explore the issue with greater nuance, and in more depth., The very presence of a community hub would have no doubt demonstrated Paperchase’s openness to discussion, quelling any doubts that they were only dealing with the situation because it went viral.

Get customers to defend your brand

If I’ve learned anything from working in online communities, it’s that an informed and engaged membership base is often willing to go out of its way to dispel misinformation among the general public. Having customers defend your brand like this is miles more effective than releasing a one-sided statement from some unseen company executive. You can’t buy this kind of love!

This is one of the most overlooked powers of communities, probably because it is harder to measure ‘brand loyalty in a crisis’ than, say, the benefits of ‘reduced call numbers’.  However, by fostering discussion, brands take a step up and show that they care what customers think. It’s hard to win when you’re fighting the fire alone, but with a community behind you, you’ve got a better chance – they will defend you effectively when it counts.

Paperchase did the right thing by listening to their customers. But having their own community would have certainly made the Twitterstorm easier to manage. It would have also tackled criticism that they only withdrew their promotion to ‘please the mob’. As Paperchase themselves said – a valuable lesson learned. And if they need any help next time… they know who to call!

 

Vincent Boon

ALSO READ…

The key to customer engagement: more trust and fewer bots

Companies keep telling me customer engagement is broken. I find this a shocking statement. We are connected to the internet 24/7, we’ve got endless tools available to speak to anyone; even my grandma uses Skype to call me on weekends. Engagement should be easier than...

Community Job Descriptions – Head of Community

The roles that are described in this series are an example of a team structure for a large and mature community and can be expanded on, depending on the specific needs of the company. Generally we would expect large Community teams to be structured using...

4 Steps To Using Data Driven Strategy For Community Engagement

Most of us have heard the phrase ‘the more the merrier’ and that holds true for our Online Forums. Increasing community engagement leads to heavily involved members that “spend up to ten times more than an average customer.” (How to Increase Sales by Vincent Boon) The...

3 reasons why brand-owned & social media communities are different

In both brand-owned and social media communities, people are interacting with each other and the brand has a presence within this - but do they both achieve the same thing? Superficially, they can feel similar but with a deeper look, we can see real...

Voice of the Customer: How to do more with less

I absolutely love to hear businesses talk about their “Voice of the Customer” programs. Whether it’s from incumbents like British Gas or challengers like Atom Bank, it’s heartwarming to hear brands giving their customer an active voice in the company. But I know, like...

Community Collaboration is the key to small business success

Launching a business is an exciting challenge, but it always comes with adversities to overcome. Elements such as low brand awareness, smaller budgets for marketing and the realisation that headcount is a huge expense can make it difficult to change the...

How a branded community would have saved Paperchase from a Twitterstorm

Paperchase recently found themselves where no brand wants to be – at the heart of a Twitterstorm. Social media users were quick to express their dismay when the company placed a promotion in the Daily Mail. Paperchase soon withdrew the promotion, apologising and...

6 Online Community Trends in 2016

It’s always hard to make predictions for the future of Community Management, without falling into the trap of writing your own wish list. Especially when you’re an enthusiast and evangelist of Online Communities like myself and fervently wish for the wider industry to...

CEM 2016 – Customer Experience Management Takeaways

Last month I was lucky enough to attend the important event about Customer Experience Management in Argentina, where experienced speakers participated and offered a very productive and interesting day. There has never been a bigger challenge in the marketing sector...

Your (grand)parents might enjoy a community

When we think about being digital, it can be easy to think it’s a young person’s game. This stems from many people associating digital expertise with a detailed understanding of the technology. This is a mistake. At Standing on Giants we see scores of older people...

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Vincent Boon

Vincent Boon

Founder

Vincent is Standing on Giants in-house community guru, futurist and troubleshooter. The source of our methodology he’s a fiery advocate for genuine customer-centric business.