We find, foster, and manage the conversations that build community and convert them into business value.
Outsourced community management that lets you scale. Multilingual community experts for forums, Discord, and Reddit.
Human, expert, multi-lingual social media community management built to create connection at scale. Community magic for social channels.
Build a safe, scalable Reddit strategy. Harness customer voice, engage authentically, and boost AI/LLM visibility.
Design, launch, or relaunch a community your business can rely on, with expert community strategy and consulting services.
Expert-led guidance and training to build skills community teams need to thrive.
Design and run programs that turn engaged members into advocates, creators and local leaders.
Turn your community into an always-on, human powered focus group.
Select and setup the right community platform for your business with independent expert help.
Find out more about the Standing on Giants team, our vision and values.
Building richer, healthier online conversation
From past to present and everything in between.
Meet the people of Standing on Giants
About employee ownership at Standing on Giants
See our current vacancies and learn about our culture.
A business for people and planet, not just profit
Listen to 'A Little Bit Radical' - our podcast on Business, People, and Planet!
Most brands that get banned or backlashed on Reddit didn’t set out to break any rules. They just moved too fast.Reddit doesn’t have one master rulebook for brands. It has thousands of subreddits, each with their own mods, their own culture, and their own long memory for anyone who’s tried to game them before. Get that wrong and you can lose more than a single post. You can lose a whole subreddit, or find your brand name quietly blacklisted from ever being mentioned there again.The good news is that the rules, once you actually know them, are learnable. This is what they really are, a handful of real examples of brands getting it wrong, a checklist to run before you post, and what it actually looks like when brands get this right.
Underneath all the local variation between subreddits, the same handful of principles show up again and again.
If you’re posting on behalf of a brand, say so, plainly. “I work at X” does all the work you need it to do. Brands that try to sound like a regular customer, rather than an employee being upfront about it, are the ones that tend to get caught out, and getting caught out does far more damage than simply disclosing in the first place would have.Disclosure is often a literal rule, too, not just good etiquette. Plenty of subreddits, especially in finance and health, require identified brand accounts to carry a specific flair before they’re allowed to post at all. Some moderators will simply tell you, kindly, that your branded account isn’t welcome, however carefully you’ve introduced yourself. Take that at face value and move on. Pushing back rarely goes well.
Reddit’s own guidance suggests roughly one self-promotional post for every nine that aren’t about you at all. Most experienced brand accounts run well under that. Treat it as a ceiling, not a target.
“Self-promotional” covers more than linking your product. Replying to a thread nobody addressed to you, or jumping in the moment your brand gets mentioned somewhere, reads the same way to a community: you’re there for you, not for them.
A few patterns come up constantly:
A junior marketer at a food brand (details changed) built a Reddit account with a name that hinted at, but didn’t confirm, her employer. She spent weeks genuinely participating, sharing recipes and opinions, and built up some goodwill. Then, under pressure for faster results, she posted a direct advertisement from the same account. A commenter called it spam. Someone else checked the username, worked out who she was, and went back through her entire post history reframing every past comment as a calculated setup. The brand walked away from Reddit for good.
A workspace and productivity brand wrote publicly about spending three months trying to build a Reddit presence, following common advice: post genuinely, then crosspost to relevant subreddits for reach. Almost none of the crossposts survived. Posts that weren’t ads at all, including one that was simply a question, got removed by bots or moderators for appearing in multiple subs at once. The same content posted personally, from personal accounts, did fine.
A financial services brand (anonymised) reached out to moderators in good faith across a shortlist of relevant subreddits before posting anything. Most didn’t respond. One did, thanked the team for actually reading the rules first, and then said plainly the branded account wasn’t welcome there. This is moderators doing their job well, and the brand’s best move was to accept it and look elsewhere.
Several B2B software subreddits have been hit hard enough by disguised brand activity over the years that moderators eventually set up automod rules removing any post mentioning specific product or company names outright. The marketers responsible moved on long ago. The blanket ban remains, and any legitimate brand trying to engage honestly today inherits it.
A pattern we see repeated across industries: a team asks colleagues or an agency to upvote a launch post to help it “get seen.” Reddit’s anti-manipulation systems are built specifically to catch coordinated voting like this, and the consequence tends to land on the domain itself, quietly limiting visibility for everything the brand links to afterwards, sometimes for a long time after anyone remembers why.
Screenshot this one. Run through it before anything goes live, first post or fiftieth.
If you can’t say yes to all ten, that’s a reason to wait a little longer or ask someone who’s done this before.
Sonos is one of the clearest examples of this. Their community lead, posting as himself rather than as a logo, has become one of the most trusted voices in the r/Sonos community, even through a rocky product launch. As he puts it, people now defend the brand unprompted, because they’ve come to see the people behind it as exactly that: people.
When Reddit feedback started carrying real weight at Sonos, their community lead began getting pulled into hardware and software release meetings, not to represent marketing, but because leadership wanted the community’s voice at the table. Done well, Reddit becomes a genuine feedback loop into product, not just a reputation exercise.
Being noticed and taken seriously in a space that’s famously sceptical of brands means something to people. A thoughtful, honest reply from someone who clearly works at the company, correcting a misunderstanding or simply acknowledging a good point, tends to land far better than the same message would anywhere else.
Graco’s first Reddit AMA in r/toddlers helped make that community the top-cited source for the brand in ChatGPT. This isn’t the reason to do it, but it’s a real and increasingly common side effect of doing it well.
Brands that have already built real credibility on Reddit have somewhere to stand when a launch goes badly or a product update lands poorly. The community that’s used to seeing you show up honestly is far more likely to hear you out when you need to explain yourself.
