We find, foster, and manage the conversations that build community and convert them into business value.
Outsourced community management that lets you scale. Multilingual community experts for forums, Discord, and Reddit.
Human, expert, multi-lingual social media community management built to create connection at scale. Community magic for social channels.
Build a safe, scalable Reddit strategy. Harness customer voice, engage authentically, and boost AI/LLM visibility.
Design, launch, or relaunch a community your business can rely on, with expert community strategy and consulting services.
Expert-led guidance and training to build skills community teams need to thrive.
Design and run programs that turn engaged members into advocates, creators and local leaders.
Turn your community into an always-on, human powered focus group.
Select and setup the right community platform for your business with independent expert help.
Find out more about the Standing on Giants team, our vision and values.
Building richer, healthier online conversation
From past to present and everything in between.
Meet the people of Standing on Giants
About employee ownership at Standing on Giants
See our current vacancies and learn about our culture.
A business for people and planet, not just profit
Listen to 'A Little Bit Radical' - our podcast on Business, People, and Planet!
Reddit is moving to a logged-in-only experience. Two days earlier, Discord said it would put its public communities on the open web. Here’s what both moves could mean for brands, AI search and the future of online community.The last week of October 2026 gave us one of the more interesting plot twists in social media.On 29 October, Reddit posted another bumper quarter. Revenue up 53%. Ad revenue up 54%. And then, almost in passing, CEO Steve Huffman confirmed that Reddit will become a logged-in-only experience.Cue the hot takes. Reddit is closing up shop. The open internet is over. The golden age of Reddit in Google is done.We’re not so sure.Reddit isn’t shrinking. It’s choosing who gets value from it for free, and who has to pay. Meanwhile Discord, the most famous walled garden in community, is heading the other way.Same problem but opposite directions. And they may end up somewhere surprisingly similar.
The money side is strong. Reddit reported $895 million in Q3 2026 revenue, up 53% year on year, with advertising bringing in $847 million of that.Revenue per user rose 36%. Reddit also joined the S&P 500.The audience side is softer. International daily users grew 24%, but growth at home has stalled. In the US, logged-in daily users grew just 1%, from 23.1 million to 23.4 million.Then came the big one. Reddit will shift to a logged-in-only experience, starting with tests in select markets outside the US this quarter. There’s no date yet for a global rollout.
A few details:
It sounds very similar to what we’ve become used to on other social media platforms.
The short answer: AI has broken the deal between Reddit and Google.
For years, someone would search a weird household problem, land on a 14-year-old Reddit thread and get their answer. Now an AI summary answers it on the results page. No click required.
Huffman said Reddit lost a million search referrals a week on average in October. Most of that hit logged-out visitors, the people Reddit earns least from anyway.
Over 80% of Reddit’s revenue already comes from logged-in and app users. Logged-in engagement is roughly five times that of logged-out.
So the maths is simple. If drive-by search traffic is drying up, stop optimising for it. Turn more visitors into members, learn more about them, and sell better-targeted ads against them.
That’s exactly what the numbers show. User growth is slow. Ad revenue is flying. Reddit is getting more from the audience it already has.
Huffman’s own reasons line up with that: better personalisation, more signals for ad targeting, protecting the data and keeping up with new regulation. As he put it, Reddit was the last platform still offering basically unfettered logged-out access.
Reddit is one of the most cited sources in AI answers. So the obvious question is whether this changes that.
Our read: Reddit’s content isn’t disappearing from AI. Access to it is getting more expensive.
Huffman was clear that most unauthorised scraping happens through logged-out pages. Close that door and anyone who wants Reddit’s conversations has to come through the official one. That means a licensing deal.
Licensing is still small in revenue terms. It sits inside “other revenue”, which was $48 million last quarter against $847 million from ads. But it’s strategically huge. Reddit is turning 20 years of human conversation into an asset you pay to use.
For brands, that creates something worth watching. Reddit’s influence in AI answers may concentrate in the models and search engines with licensing agreements, and weaken in those without.
None of the details are confirmed yet. Reddit itself says the line between logged-in and logged-out is still being worked out. But it’s a good reason not to treat Reddit’s AI visibility as a fixed, universal constant.
Two days before Reddit’s news, Discord went the other way.On 27 October, Discord announced that its public communities would become searchable on the open web. Here’s how it works:
The reasoning is the mirror image of Reddit’s. Huge amounts of useful knowledge, from game guides to technical fixes, are locked inside Discord chats. Nobody outside can find it, so nobody new finds the community.
It’s tempting to read these as two unrelated announcements. We think they’re the same story.AI has broken the old search-to-click economy. Both platforms are rebuilding around it, just from opposite starting points.
Both end up with the same model. A public shop window that search engines and AI can see. A members’ club where the real value, data and engagement live.The split between them may settle along format lines. Reddit for asynchronous, searchable discussion. Discord for synchronous, real-time community.By publishing AI summaries of its chats, Discord is effectively turning live conversation into searchable, async content. That’s Reddit’s home turf, and it’ll be fascinating to see how well chat holds up out of context.
If you’ve been treating Reddit purely as an SEO or AI visibility play, this is your nudge to rethink.
The platforms are changing their front doors. The fundamentals of the human-powered internet haven’t moved an inch.
Yes, eventually. Reddit is moving to a logged-in-only experience, with tests starting in select markets outside the US in Q4 2026. There’s no global rollout date yet, and the front page will stay visible to logged-out visitors.
Search referrals are falling as AI answers replace clicks. Logged-in users engage more and drive over 80% of Reddit’s revenue. Logging in also gives Reddit better ad targeting and more control over who accesses its data.
Probably, but how much is unclear. Reddit says visitors arriving from search should still see linked content before being asked to log in. AI tools with licensing deals are likely to keep access, while unlicensed scrapers may lose it.
From 16 November 2026, every Discoverable Server gets a public web page. From mid-December, selected messages from public channels can appear in search results, without usernames or avatars.
Yes. Server admins choose which channels are included, and individual members can opt out. Private servers and DMs aren’t affected.
