Online communities are great for connection, collaboration, and shared experiences. But let’s be honest – not every comment comes wrapped in kindness. Sometimes people bring tension or negativity. And as community managers, it’s on us to figure out whether someone’s just venting or trying to stir the pot.
While some comments should be hidden right away, not everything is clear cut. Some posts fall into the grey area – not quite a violation, but still disruptive. That’s when a more thoughtful, case-by-case approach matters. At Standing on Giants, we use the REACT framework to handle tricky situations with empathy and consistency. Here’s how we handle the “is this just frustration, or are they becoming a problem?” moments and what we’ve learned along the way.
Not all disruptive behaviour is loud or constant. Some people show up occasionally with negativity, disappear, and then come back with more. They might not be breaking rules, but they still affect the tone and wellbeing of the space.
So how do you decide when to step in or when to keep offering support?
R – REVIEW THE USER’S HISTORY
Zoom out. Are they always negative, or just occasionally frustrated? Have they added value before? Look at tone, timing, and patterns. One rough day doesn’t mean bad intentions but repeated friction might.
E – EVALUATE THE NATURE OF THEIR COMMENTS
Is the criticism fair, or are they getting personal? Look for language meant to provoke or undermine. If a comment crosses the line, escalate internally. Some people just aren’t a good fit for the space.
A – ASSESS WILLINGNESS TO ACCEPT SUPPORT
Do they respond when help is offered? Frustrated members usually engage, even a little. Trolls tend to ignore support, reject it, or vanish until their next flare-up. No engagement is a red flag.
C – CONSIDER THE TIME FRAME
How often is this happening? Someone venting once every few months might just need space. But if the same complaints keep showing up despite past help, that points to a deeper issue. Frequency and predictability matter.
T – TAKE THOUGHTFUL ACTION
If the person seems open or the issue is isolated, keep the door open. But if the pattern continues, start documenting it. You may eventually need to add them to a Do Not Engage list and focus on protecting the wider community.
And if you’re on the fence – ask your team. A second opinion helps.
The Takeaway
Moderation isn’t about shutting down criticism. It’s about keeping the space safe for constructive conversation. The grey area is where judgment matters more than rules.
Not every negative comment is a red flag. Not every tough member is a troll.
But with a clear process, context, and a supportive team, you’ll know when to show patience and when to draw the line.
More from the blog
